Was It A Catch?

As many fans are getting ready for another day of football, I have found myself not interested in the games yet again.  Being a Dallas Cowboys and Pittsburgh Steelers fan, I could care less about the rest of football season.  I, like many others, thought we were going to see another Dallas vs. Pittsburgh Superbowl, however, my thoughts were put to an end after first Pittburgh lost following with a Dallas loss the following week.  I find myself still unable to get over the call that was the huge turn around for Dallas.

For those that are unaware of the call that was made, Dez Bryant made a catch that was challenged by Green Bay’s coach and was later reversed.

The ruling states “”If a player goes to the ground in the act of catching a pass (with or without contact by an opponent), he must maintain control of the ball throughout the process of contacting the ground, whether in the field of play or the end zone. If he loses control of the ball, and the ball touches the ground before he regains control, the pass is incomplete. If he regains control prior to the ball touching the ground, the pass is complete.”  It appears that Dez Bryant never lost control of the ball and this was indeed a catch.  While this call isn’t what cost Dallas the game, as it either would have ended with a tie or Dallas taking one point lead.

The question is, was it a catch?  I myself feel as if it was and have heard many others agree, likewise I have heard others disagree.  What do you think?

dez-bryant-catch-packers  nfl635565907529943344-USATSI-8325589

Advertisements

Calling for a Buzzer!

Those that did not watch the University of Kentucky and University of Florida football game Saturday, September 13, missed an excellent game.   UK has had a 27-year losing streak to Florida prior to this game, and many people expected the streak to continue.  After three overtimes, fans, players, and coaches were able to hold their heads high even after falling short 30-36.  The question many are asking, should this game have even gone into a second overtime?  Did Florida actually luck into this win?

10255031_754321697963366_3118588006547468523_n

College football writer, Jerry Hinnen, stated, “Despite a handful of controversial calls occurring in the Georgia-South Carolina game, no Week 3 officiating decision was more hotly contested in SEC country than the absence of a delay of game flag on a critical fourth-and-7 for Florida in the first overtime of the Gators’ eventual 36-30 victory against Kentucky.”


The SEC released the following statement about the controversial call: “At the request of the University of Kentucky, consistent with SEC protocol, the conference office reviewed the fourth down play in the first overtime of the Kentucky-Florida game and has determined the officials applied the proper mechanics and guidelines that are in place to determine when a flag should be thrown for delay of game. The back judge is responsible for delay of game calls. The procedure for the back judge is for his eyes to stay on the clock when it nears zero. When the clock hits zero, he immediately looks from the clock to the ball. If the ball is moving, there is no delay of game. If the ball is stationary, a delay of game penalty is called.” Isn’t this a lot for one person to do?  After reading over the statement again, I noticed that there was actually no comment about the call, all that was said was that the back judge followed the procedure.

This no-call not only affected the outcome of the University of Kentucky football game but countless games as well. One recent game is the Green Bay Packers and the Chicago Bears.  Instead of relying on the back judge to watch the clock and the ball, there should be a buzzer (like the shot clock in basketball) to go off when the timer hits zero.  Even though a buzzer wouldn’t completely stop the controversial call of delay of game, it would help to reduce the margin of error.

SOURCES
http://www.cbssports.com/collegefootball/eye-on-college-football/24710707/sec-issues-statement-on-florida-kentucky-delay-of-game-call
http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2014/09/14/packers-take-31-24-win-in-wild-one-against-the-jets/